Super Chevy
Click here to find out more!

Chevy Small Block Cam - Separation Of Power

Does Lobe Separation Really Matter?

By Mike Petralia

Did you know that you could take two cams that are ground with EXACTLY the same lobes, even from the same cam company, and still get one to make about 20 more horsepower than the other? It's the lobe separation that does the trick, and if you picked the wrong separation figure, you could be losing power. We think the cam manufacturers do this just to keep us guessing because it's an area where camshaft design and technology can get very confusing.

What Is Lobe Separation?
Lobe separation angle is NOT the same thing as the lobe centerlines, although it does directly involve them. Lobe separation is the number of degrees between the point when the exhaust valve reaches maximum lift and the point that the intake valve reaches maximum lift. Those two max lift points are the lobe centerlines and usually fall somewhere in the 102- to 122-degree range.

You can calculate lobe separation by adding the intake and exhaust lobe centerline figures together and dividing the sum by 2 (Ex: 110 intake center line + 114 exhaust center line= 224/2= 112 lobe separation). This also is the figure needed to determine how much the intake lobe may be "advanced." To calculate intake lobe advance, simply subtract the intake lobe centerline from the lobe separation angle (112-110= 2). The difference is how much advance is ground into your cam, 2 degrees in this example. It's also important to remember that you cannot change lobe separation or intake lobe advance after the cam is ground. Lobe separation is not the same as valve overlap either, as some people mistakenly identify it. Overlap is simply the degrees that both valves are open at the same time (see diagram).

Typically with street cams, the farther you spread the lobe centers apart with a wide lobe-separation angle, like 116 degrees, the less overlap you get. Although both wide (112-116) and narrow (102-110) lobe-separation angles do have some effect on overlap, it's still possible to get tons of overlap with a very wide lobe-separation angle. Race cams like those used in Pro Stock and Pro nitrous applications usually have a very high lobe-separation angle of 116 degrees and above, yet still have lots of overlap because the intake vale opens very early in the cycle while the exhaust valve has not closed very far yet.

It's the scavenging effect caused by this that pulls the fresh fuel/air charge into the chamber. Why is all this important? It all has to do with the cylinder heads, exhaust system, and how well the engine will breathe. If you've got inefficient cylinder heads or a poor-breathing exhaust system, the wrong lobe separation angle might not pull enough fresh charge into the cylinder and you'd lose power

The Power Of Separation
How much effect a wide vs. narrow lobe-separation angle has on power is precisely what we wanted to test, so Comp Cams ground five identical-duration solid roller camshafts with a different lobe-separation angle on each for us to try. The test was simple: Install all five cams straight up in the same engine with no changes in between. Since we wanted to cover the broadest separation spectrum for street cams, we asked Comp to grind 106-, 108-, 110-, 112-, and 114-degree lobe separations to see how that alone would affect power.

Our rather mild small-block was a 0.030-over 350 using a few good-breathing parts to make power. Basically, our tests showed that most of today's cam manufacturers have it correct when they grind their cams with a 108-110-lobe-separation angle, because it was within this range that our test motor worked the best. The difference in peak power, made between the best and worst cams, was more than 20 hp with the 108-lobe cam making the most at 475 hp and the 112-lobe cam making the least at 452 hp.

This proves that the entire package is very important to consider when choosing the correct camshaft, and in most cases you'd be wise to consult an expert, not your buddies unless they're also cam experts, when selecting the perfect cam. As we learned in our tests, any cam can work well, but some cams can work better than others.

Separating the Power
Look closely at the two power curves for all cams. Note how the 106 and 110 lobes practically duplicate each other. Comp explained that since the engine we tested used a single-plane intake manifold and open headers, it breathed well and didn't need much help scavenging the cylinders. The 106 cam probably over-scavenged just a bit too much, and the 110 probably under-scavenged an equal amount, so the dyno pulls look almost identical.

Since the 108 lobe performed best, it showed that this engine liked only a little scavenging, and the 112 and 114 lobes' poor performance meant the this engine liked to breathe with a little bit more overlap to make the best power. The average and maximum power figures tell the biggest story. One true benefit to running a higher-lobe-separation cam is a better idle quality with more vacuum, so we listed vacuum at 1,000 rpm for each cam to compare. These results represent horsepower averaged from three consecutive dyno pulls with each cam.

Horsepower
L/S 106 108 110 112 114
RPM HP HP HP HP HP
3600 258 262 261 264 261
3800 281 384 282 283 280
4000 311 311 308 307 302
4200 333 338 333 330 325
4400 353 362 356 352 347
4600 375 382 375 373 369
4800 393 399 392 390 386
5000 409 415 409 407 404
5200 427 432 429 424 421
5400 441 446 444 435 436
5600 453 458 455 445 446
5800 459 465 461 449 451
6000 464 470 465 451 453
6200 469 474 469 452* 455*
6400 470* 476* 470* 449 453
Avg 387 392 388 382 380
Max 470 475 470 452 455
Vac 10” 12” 13” 14.5” 15”
Torque
L/S 106 108 110 112 114
RPM TQ TQ TQ TQ TQ
3600 377 382 381 385 380
3800 389 393 390 392 386
4000 409 409 405 404 397
4200 416 423 416 413 406
4400 421 432 425 420 414
4600 428 437* 428 426 421
4800 431* 436 429 427 422
5000 430 436 430 427 424
5200 431 436 433* 429* 425*
5400 429 434 432 423 424
5600 425 429 426 417 418
5800 416 421 417 406 409
6000 406 412 407 395 397
6200 397 402 397 383 386
6400 385 391 385 369 372
Avg 414 419 415 409 407
Max 431 437 433 429 425
SOURCES
COMP Cams Iskenderian Racing Cams
16020 South Broadway,
Dept. MMFF
Gardena
CA  90247-9990
Crane Cams
530 Fentress Blvd.
Daytona Beach
FL  32114
3-86/-252-1151
N/A
www.cranecams.com
Jesel Inc.
1985 Cedarbridge Avenue
Dept. MMFF
Lakewood
NJ  08701
Crower Cams
San Diego
CA
619-661-6477
www.crower.com
Westech Performance Group
11098 Venture Dr., Unit C
Mira Loma
CA  91752
9-09/-685-4767
www.westechperformance.com
Erson Cams
550 Mallory Way
Carson City
NV  89701
775-882-6600
www.mrgasket.com/erson.htm
  • «
  • |
  • 1
  • |
  • 2
  • |
  • View Full Article
By Mike Petralia
Enjoyed this Post? Subscribe to our RSS Feed, or use your favorite social media to recommend us to friends and colleagues!
Super Chevy