Subscribe to the Free
Newsletter

Camshaft Design and Theory Q&A

Ten bumpstick basics of cam design and theory

Barry Kluczyk Apr 24, 2017 0 Comment(s)
View Full Gallery

If we were to ask for a show of hands, it’s a safe bet to assume many enthusiasts would reluctantly admit that camshaft theory is one of those topics that causes more than a little consternation. You know the basics of lift and duration and probably the difference between hydraulic and solid lifter cams, but as for aspects beyond those, such as centerline, lobe separation angle, overlap, and more there’s no harm in admitting if you struggle a bit.

Hey, we get it. Camshaft theory is a complex science with a lot of ins and a lot of outs, to paraphrase the great Jeffrey Lebowski. More than how much the camshaft lifts the valves off their seats and how long it holds them open, centerlines, lobe separation angles, overlap, and more contribute to how it affects engine performance.

We’re not discussing the finer points of lobe ramp angles with this story, but simply explaining some of the basic terms and general theories of camshaft design and operation. It’s a back-to-basics overview intended to lay a foundation for greater understanding. And while it should help you discuss the subject more authoritatively and decipher the specs camshaft manufacturers list in their catalog descriptions, it’s not a guide to selecting the perfect camshaft for your engine.

You need to talk to the experts for that. All the major camshaft manufacturers have tech lines and online options to help select the best camshaft for the job. Use them and you’ll have a better idea of what the hell they’re talking about!

1. What are the differences between flat tappet camshafts and roller camshafts?

Simply put, a flat tappet camshaft is used with flat-faced lifters (well, mostly flat), while roller cams are used with lifters with roller tips. The roller tips greatly reduce friction, offer greater performance and efficiency while also reducing maintenance because the valvetrain requires virtually no adjustments. Flat tappet camshafts come in two varieties: solid and hydraulic. The solid flat tappet cam is commonly called a solid lifter camshaft because it has a solid interface with the pushrod. A hydraulic flat tappet cam uses lifters with oil-pressurized pistons to maintain their connection with the pushrods. Flat tappet designs require periodic valve lash inspections or adjustments, but not nearly as often these days as in the old muscle car era. They also generate considerably more friction than a roller design and wear much faster. Generally, flat tappet camshafts open and close the valves slower than roller cams, which tend to open them and snap them closed quickly. For a street or street/strip engine, the roller design is the way to go.

Cam Theory 002 2/15

One of the big benefits with a roller cam is that the lobe shape isn’t limited by the profile of the flat tappet lifter, which will dig into a too-aggressively angled lobe. Therefore, there is more freedom in roller cam design because the lifter’s roller tip will simply ride over the lobe regardless of its ramp angle.

Cam Theory Roller Lifters 003 3/15

Using a roller cam and roller-tip lifters allows more tappet lift to be achieved without the corresponding need for increased duration that would be required for a safe flat tappet design. It also enables a broader lift curve without increasing the lift specification itself.

2. I know the basics of lift and duration, but what’s important about their relationship?

Lift is the measurement of how far the valve lifts off its seat, while duration is the amount of time the valve remains open, expressed in degrees of crankshaft rotation. That means a camshaft with 245 degrees of duration holds the valve open as the crankshaft rotates 245 of 360 degrees. Both aspects of valve actuation work together to optimize airflow in and out of the cylinders, but the lift and duration rates have different effects on performance. Generally speaking, more duration will help build horsepower at higher rpm, typically at the expense of low-end torque. A little more lift and a little less duration can help achieve comparable power without the torque penalty as long as the cylinder heads flow well. More lift is useless otherwise and, in fact, can work against the engine combination, because more valvespring tension is typically required with a high-lift camshaft—and that generates more power-robbing friction.

Cam Theory Valves 004 4/15

Lift and duration are all about the valves—how much they lift off their seats (lift) and how long they stay off of them (duration). That combination determines how much air flows in and out of the cylinders, but it’s a delicate balance because it’s very easy to overdo it with more than the cylinder heads can handle.

Cam Theory Valve Springs 005 5/15

A consequence of too much lift can be coil bind, where the valvesprings’ coils touch one another and cannot travel any farther. That can be disastrous for the camshaft and the rest of the valvetrain. A safety margin of at least 0.060 inch between the spring travel and the full lift of the valve is required, making it all the more important to consult the tech experts at your cam manufacturer of choice and match the camshaft with the correct valvetrain components.

3. Aren’t there several types of lift specifications? Which one should I care about?

When reading advertised cam specs, the basic “lift” specification refers to the maximum lift of the valve off its seat and that’s the important number. The nuance here is that this valve lift measurement is based on multiplying two other specs: the gross lift of the camshaft, which is the distance a cam lobe moves the tappet (lifter) and the rocker arm ratio. Let’s say the camshaft moves the lifter 0.275-inch and the rocker arm ratio is 1.5:1. Multiplying them brings a max valve lift of 0.4125 inch. And if you’ve heard that increasing the rocker arm ratio brings an effective valve lift increase, you’re correct. Moving up to a 1.6:1 ratio rocker and staying with the same camshaft would change the max valve lift to 0.440 inch.

Cam Theory 007 6/15

The rocker arm ratio, which is the length of the valve side of the rocker arm to the center (pivot point) of the rocker arm divided by the length of the camshaft side of the arm, is a contributor to the maximum valve lift in conjunction with the camshaft. To put it simply: a 1.5:1 ratio rocker arm means that for each 0.100-inch of camshaft motion (via the pushrod), you get 0.150 inches of valve motion. Increasing the rocker arm ratio provides an effective increase in valve lift without having to change the cam.

4. What is the difference between advertised duration and duration at 0.050-inch?

Good question. It’s all about where the duration is measured, which must be at some point of lifter rise. The measurement is the angle in crankshaft degrees between the matching lift points on the opening and closing sides of the cam lobe. Let’s say the measurement is 0.005 inch. The duration measurement starts when the lifter rises 0.005 inch on the opening side of the cam lobe’s rotation and concludes when it gets back to 0.005 inch on the closing side. The angle between those points—265 degrees, for example—is the advertised duration. The problem is, not all manufacturers’ advertised duration numbers are measured from the same point. Some are at 0.004-inch lift to show a really big number, while others stick to the SAE spec of 0.006-inch. The cam manufacturers also rate their duration specs at 0.050-inch lift for standardized comparison purposes. The numbers are considerably “smaller” than the advertised duration, but the 0.050-inch spec allows the cams of different manufacturers to be easily crosschecked.

Cam Theory Chart 006 7/15

This typical camshaft catalog listing shows the duration at 0.050-inch lift on the left and the advertised duration to the right. The advertised spec is larger, but what it doesn’t show is the lift at which the measurement was taken, making it impossible to compare with the advertised duration of another manufacturer. The 0.050-inch spec is universal among manufacturers.

5. What the heck is a “dual-pattern” camshaft?

It’s a camshaft that has different duration specifications for the intake and exhaust lobes, whereas a single-pattern camshaft has the same specs for both. The dual-pattern cam has more duration (and more lift) for the exhaust lobes to enhance airflow for cylinder heads with less-than-adequate exhaust ports. Better-flowing aftermarket heads these days have reduced the need for dual-pattern cams, but they boost performance on older, stock head designs.

Cam Theory 008 8/15

Single-pattern vs. dual-pattern cams are pretty easy to understand: If the camshaft has 272 degrees of duration on the intake and exhaust lobes, for example, it’s a single-pattern camshaft. If the intake duration was perhaps 272 degrees and the exhaust was 282 degrees, it’s a dual-pattern camshaft. Dual-pattern cams are designed to make the most of lower-flowing exhaust ports.

6. What is overlap and how does it affect performance?

Overlap is the brief period where the intake and exhaust valves for a cylinder are open (off their seats) simultaneously, measured in degrees of crankshaft rotation. This is intentional because as the exhaust gases are pulled out of the combustion chamber a scavenging effect is created that helps pull the next mixture into the chamber—and the greater the duration generated by the camshaft, the greater the overlap. The intricacies of overlap theory are very complicated, but generally speaking, more overlap benefits performance at high rpm because it helps fill the cylinders. Overlap also accounts for that awesome low-rpm lope at idle—lots of overlap to build power at high rpm. The trade-off is reduced torque and low vacuum production, which isn’t a problem on the dragstrip, but affects driveability in street cars. Then again, it sure sounds good on cruise night.

Cam Theory 009 9/15

A lot of overlap sounds great and helps drag cars optimize performance by enhancing airflow scavenging at high rpm but it’s mostly a hindrance on the street because low-rpm power suffers and low vacuum production affects power brake performance.

7. What is the lobe separation angle and why is it important?

Lobe separation angle (LSA) is the measurement in camshaft degrees between the maximum lift points—known as centerlines—of the intake and exhaust lobes. Simply put, it affects the engine’s power curve, idle quality, vacuum production, and more through its effect on valve overlap. A tighter (narrower) LSA contributes to a narrow powerband that moves torque lower in the rpm range, while increasing overlap for high-rpm horsepower. A rougher idle and lower vacuum at idle are byproducts. On the other hand, a wider LSA broadens the powerband and moves torque higher in the rpm range. There’s less overlap, which enhances idle quality and vacuum. Supercharged engines generally benefit more from a wider LSA because they don’t require the scavenging effects that come with greater overlap.

Cam Lsa 010 10/15

The lobe separation angle (LSA) is calculated by adding the intake and exhaust centerlines and dividing the product by two. That means a camshaft with a 110-degree intake centerline and a 118-degree exhaust centerline would have a lobe separation angle of 114 degrees.

Twin Turbo Engine 011 11/15

Forced-induction engines typically run camshafts with wider LSAs because they don’t require the high-rpm scavenging that comes with naturally aspirated engines featuring tighter LSAs that promotes greater overlap.

8. What is the camshaft centerline and why does it matter?

It is the halfway point between the intake and exhaust centerlines. The intake centerline is the point of highest lift on the intake lobe, expressed in crankshaft degrees, after top dead center (ATDC). The exhaust centerline is the point of highest lift on the exhaust lobe before top dead center (BTDC). What’s important here is the intake centerline on the intake lobe for cylinder No. 1, which is used to determine accurate camshaft timing. The manufacturer lists the intake centerline on the supplied cam card, but that specification may not translate exactly when the camshaft is installed, even when the marks on the cam and timing gear are aligned—although it is generally very close. Degreeing the camshaft will determine the correct installed intake centerline for spot-on timing.

Cam Theory Centerpoint 012 12/15

The intake centerline is the point of highest lift on the intake lobe, expressed in crankshaft degrees after top dead center (ATDC). Similarly, the exhaust centerline is the point of highest lift on the exhaust lobe, but expressed in crankshaft degrees before top dead center (BTDC). The cam centerline is halfway between the intake and exhaust centerlines.

9. What is degreeing a camshaft and is it really necessary?

Degreeing ensures the most accurate valve actuation by correcting errors and accounting for tolerances involved with the machining process of the camshaft. In other words, it is a procedure that verifies the camshaft’s just-right position for spot-on timing. It involves checking the cam lobes at a specified lift in relation to the crankshaft’s position. The larger question is whether it’s necessary. Short answer: Not really. For most stock-type rebuilds and even moderate performance builds, degreeing doesn’t necessarily deliver an advantage. The accuracy of computer-based machining has made modern camshafts very accurate out of the box. Most camshaft manufacturers build a little advance—about 4 degrees—into the grind. Degreeing the camshaft can’t hurt and is recommended for max performance, but don’t worry about simply lining up the dots on the timing gears and calling it good. It will work.

Cam Degreeing Theory 013 13/15

Degreeing the camshaft is a procedure that ensures optimal cam timing. Tools required for the project include a degree wheel to mount on the crankshaft, a pointer to indicate points on the wheel, a dial indicator to measure cam lift, and a Top Dead Center (TDC) piston stop. Cam-tuning kits with all of that equipment are available from most camshaft manufacturers.

10. What does installing a camshaft “straight up” mean?

It means the camshaft is installed during degreeing to the recommended intake centerline specification. The spec is indicated on the cam card included with a new camshaft. The intake centerline, you will recall from above, is the highest point of lift on the intake lobe. The camshaft’s installed position can be advanced or retarded relative to the straight up specification, altering camshaft timing and therefore valve actuation to shift the engine’s torque band. For example, a camshaft with a 108-degree intake centerline will be centered at 104 degrees when installed 4 degrees advanced. Conversely, the intake centerline will effectively be 112 degrees when retarded 4 degrees. An advanced cam opens the intake valve a little sooner and generally enhances low-rpm power and throttle response. A retarded cam delays the intake valve’s opening, pushing power production higher in the rpm band. As mentioned earlier, most aftermarket camshafts have a little advance built into them.

Cam Install 014 14/15

Advancing or retarding the camshaft, relative to the “straight up” position shifts the engine’s torque band by altering the valve events ahead of or behind the movement of the piston. Experimenting with the position is the best way to determine what works best for the engine and its intended operational range.

Cam Theory 015 15/15

This simple diagram illustrates the variances of a straight-up camshaft installation, along with advanced and retarded. The positions are based on the intake lobe centerline ATDC.

Photos: Barry Kluczyk

Sources

Lunati
662-892-1500
www.lunatipower.com
Crane Cams
Daytona Beach, FL 32117
866-388-5120
http://www.cranecams.com
Comp Cams
Memphis, TN 38118
901-795-2400
http://www.compcams.com
Isky Racing Cams
Gardena, CA 90248
310-217-9232
www.iskycams.com
Howards Cams
Oshkosh, Wi 54902
www.howardscams.com

MORE PHOTOS

VIEW FULL GALLERY
X

COMMENTS

Connect With Us

Get Latest News and Articles. Newsletter Sign Up

sponsored links

subscribe to the magazine

get digital get print
CLOSE X
BUYER'S GUIDE
SEE THE ALL NEW
NEWS, REVIEWS & SPECS
TO TOP